Geoffrey Schofield REVIEWS My Training Book || Digital Discrimination || Intensity vs. Intensiveness

I watched that guys video for about 2 min before I changed it. Couldn't stay interested. I have Greg's book and know it works. The other guy doesn't even look like he trains and have no clue who he is or what he even does.

60k views for a channel with almost a million subs? Lol your channel fell off, good riddance

Your book seems expensive. Plus we know whats in your book "Try harder than last time! " thats like $10 a letter.

Greg, you have become your own worst enemy... Unsubscribed.

Come on, Greg. People are expecting pictures, when the book is for beginners. Alright. You didn’t put them. Then maybe make an app, that you can use only after you purchase the book and in the app show how to do each exercise. Yes, it’s easy to google exercises, but gyms are full with people doing the exercises wrong. So, when they pay 200 dollars, they deserve to have the exercises explained. They aren’t being lazy for not googling it. You’re being lazy for not putting the necessary information in. Smh

That filler remark really triggered Greg.

Both fair reviews both shit on each other, thanks for the information.

Greg did Geoff dirty in this rebuttal, but for all I know it could be an inside joke. Geoff had a negative opinion of Greg at first, then looked a little deeper and decided Greg was better than first impression would indicate. As far as the books go if you could only get one book and tried to base your early training off of it, you could do that with Geoff's book. SWEAT reminds me of back when I started with a pile of cinder blocks and a copy of Arnold Schwarzenegger's Encyclopedia of Modern Bodybuilding. Books like that were $12, $16, up to $25 for a really big one.(I'm pre-Internet Age BTW) If I was a kid now, or someone who only got occasional Internet service or electricity, a hard copy of SWEAT would get me started and have good knowledge of the things to know regarding exercising. Greg may have written his book for the average person trying to get in better shape, but I got the impression you'd need to have some prior fitness knowledge to benefit from the book. If I gotta Google to see what the different exercises look like, ExRx and a crapload of AMhistory videos are available for the cost of Internet access.

At 15:36 Geoffry is complaining about not a single picture.. That Geoffrey guy writes lots of posts on Quora, every single post of his contains at least one picture as a marketting gimmick., to try to draw eyes to whatever he writes, to detract from the reality that often there isn't much content there and he's just answering a daft question to get some more advertising for himself. This Geoffrey guy has only been training for 5 years!

You're trying to play the AMhistory game harder than last time with this one, Greg, because your review of his review was really unfair. I say this as someone that doesn't even like Geoffrey that much.

Him calling THTLT filler shows he didn't do nearly enough research before his review.

Good job cutting to the point coach Greg simple to understand

Jeff nippard programs are good if you change all the rpes to 9 or 10 😂

This guy is selling a textbook, greg is selling his program

I like when it's starts "harder than last time "

Why would anyone buy this Geoff guys training book? The guy looks like he's been training for all of 6 months.

Why you have to defend yourself from all the spectrum of idiots? He has written the book for months and he has even worked 50% less than you. Very nice try to cover lack of knowledge, experience, writing schedule and respect-yes, we can make a joke about Greg's voice, mimics, appearance etc, but he is, without a question, top expert in his topics. In the end, I have noticed a rise of ''more spews for more views'', now, when he has risen close to one MILLION!!! So, spewers, spew somewhere else, here is not ''working''

Abby Sharper than last time

Lmao at all the fake comments from bots. Desperate move to build hype

If the information works and people pay for it...then...it's worth $200. Are you people that dumb? It's like no one gives coach credit. Dontcha think if his book was worthless and wasn't selling...he might I don't know...drop the price or put more fucking pictures in it? So obviously his book is great. STFU and don't buy it then.

This schofield clown completely misunderstands or outright doesn't get greg's material.

You’ve become a joke Greg. Sad to see how bad your content has become.

Lol you don’t need to write a training book with 100 pages .

the picture criticism is valid. examples a pictures help a lot

come on Coach, he’s a nice guy and you did him wrong.

I'm a fan of Greg. But if this book was years in the making I would expect some diagrams of the exercises as part of that time taken to write it.

Greg's followers are non morons who know how to call him out

This is probably the only time when I'd disagree with u Greg. U got Geoff completely wrong. He didn't mean to say bad about ur book or u. U wouldn't have got it this much wrong if u had infact watched the video that Geoff made, completely without skipping any part of it. At the end of the video, Geoff also said that he's ur fan and the price of ur book is completely justified because of the hardwork that u put into ur book and ur content on youtube in general. Anyway, I'm still gonna follow both of u cus both of u are great according to me. Take it as a request from a loyal subscriber of urs.... Just go and watch Geoff's video with a cool mind. Big ups 💪❤

Man, I had been digging both you and Geoffrey's content lately because both are usually fact-based, no-bullshit, fair, informative, and entertaining. This "rebuttal" was a fucking joke though! Made you look like a big, overmuscled baby. Go back and actually watch the review, and then do a response to it if you want.

Isn’t Greg actually doing this guy a favor?

This is obviously an attempt to promote his own book by comparing it to Greg’s. Expand your influence by showcasing someone with a larger following. Clout chasing harder than last time.

This guy is a dumb ass if he looks or even reads NASM does what coach Greg talks about I’m sorry Greg but I cannot listen to this idiot has he ever done a competition or trained people that are old like 65 with knee problems real people

I didn't know i was buy a picture book not a training book lol

Yo coach Greg got more muscle flex than the $8 guy so I vote for coach Greg.

Wow I was surprised to see so much criticism on this video i had to check it out. I must say if the book is for 95% of people but way less than 95% of people know what the exercises look like, is it worth $199?

WTF!! SERIOUSLY. Smh. This title is hilarious and ridiculous simultaneously. But I dare to hopefully be ENTERTAINED. Let's see. 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤷🏽‍♂️

Ahh doc you pulled an Abby Sharp in this video 😐

Just visually who would you rather have coach you. Geoff's review alone is confusing, a simple plan to lay a foundation for advanced training Coach Grey has been my guide steering me through and away from misinformation and complication.

this guy..... coach is better

What did he say!! Y’all are dumb and saying Geoff gave him praise! The only thing he said Greg had was motivation and consistency! The fuck is up with y’all! Watch the video harder then last time! You short attention spam idiots!

Hi Greg, i have to say that the lack of picture is indeed a weak point that you should and could have fixed. You need to be coherent with your own words and choices. You imply that your clients are not smart enough to read and get more details that yo uconsider unnecessary, you have a point. But then you say youre client are smarter and don't need some indications. One day they don't need to know more, one day they already know more. ALso, in your cookbook you did all the convenience work to make it easy to find the (impossibly) hard to find ingredients (after months I steel can't find many of those even by ordering online because they don't deliver out of US, Canada...), but in your training book you don't show in image what you're talking about? because people can "google" it ... people can google anything and find anything. You don't by a book to google what's missing in it.... you may as well just google all the informations then .

his book is called 'sweat' lmaoo

Greg's books are actually worth every penny more than last time

Freakin' hilarious at 07:33 jajajaja

$200 is a lot of money when you can pirate it for free!!

This books is like shit. I can share it free

This just makes Greg seem like a bit of a d*ck tbh

I can’t even imagine how long it must have taken you to make that book because it took me forever just to make my own one workout

Love your content Greg, but I'm sure if Geoffrey wasn't a fan of yours he'd probably had gone for the throat. He was being so generous with you and giving you the benefit of the doubt, saying mainly nice things about it despite its price.

By the looks of what that guy looks like, maybe he shouldn't just buy your training book, maybe he should start training from it as well..

99% of people aren't going to pay $200 for a book on fitness and personally i think its a bit scummy, greg can charge what he wants but this is a hard money grab, the $100 cookbook is bad enough do you want to help people improve their lives or do you want to make a lot of money? 99% of the content now is just fake drama for more fans, the natty or not stuff was entertaining even if its low content trash but this marketing fake drama is really bottom of the barrel

“Train harder than the last time” is the single most important phrase ever uttered in the world of weightlifting. Greg lives rent free in this losers head.

You know... putting aside all feelings and personal bias aside... If you read an ebook and u see the name/variant of an exercise that you aren't familiar with, will it be easier and more convenient to simply click it in the contents page or scroll down to the appendix to see pictures and description of it? Or is it better to spend a minute to search it on Google without assurance that it's right or the correct variant being referred to. As a beginner without prior knowledge of any exercises that is.

Listening to this guys review is a headache. Like how many times does Greg have to say it’s for the average circle. I feel like most of these trainers were never athletes and that’s why they thing average people should do the same things. Complicated stuff for beginners also just gets them anxious and takes the fun out of starting to workout. Most people who loose the weight and keep it off, start slow and train how Greg talks about. A beginnger doesn’t need to know about paused reps and shit. Good lord I almost have to stop watching this video Bc the reviewer is just ridiculous! Ugh just shut up dude! We get it you think you are intelligent and you want to show the world. Good for you buddy

Well it sounds like someone is jealous. I would rather pay more for a product that actually works. When you buy cheap stuff you get cheap results.

Greg Doucette is becoming the new AthleanX of AMhistory. He rose in popularity and people finally got to see his true colours.

i think people who want to learn how to train dont want a $8 Dr Seus picture book and would rather have a $200 manual...

I lost it when he said “that’s just lazy”🤣🤣🤣. Dude looks like 25-30% body fat, and the $9 book I almost shit myself laughing so hard.🤣

Critiques, debates, and conversations is how AMhistory works right now. Our doctor answered doubts about his book. Geoffrey should be thankful that someone with 85 times more subs than him mentioned him.

This is definitely a hit to Greg's reputation.

Haha, Greg fanboys actually think he is in the right here

After watching Geoffreys whole video I do think you got a little angry near the end Coach! He was having a fair opinion and being pretty respectful! This video started great, just think you punched too hard at the end. Still love it tho! Don't yell at me!!

Watch your ego Greg, it's inflating. And yes $200 for a book is pricey for an advice you can find free these days.

It’s just ultimate cringetopia seeing all these small time AMhistoryrs doing anything they can to get a repost on Greg’s channel, honestly from that skinny dude who reviewed his cookbook to this guy they’re all just dickriding LOL

Greg should have included pictures.

This edit had me rolling!! Shout out to editor Steve!!

How bout just adding a link in a training book showing videos of you demonstrating proper form or maybe just give them a different link through email when they buy your training book. I mean it would not take more than hour to record it and the length of book would be the same

I was debating on whether to make this comment because I'm a fan of Greg and have personally benefited from his videos especially his dietary advice but I'm just gonna call it is as I see it. This isn't a situation like with those guys who made false allegations on the coach. Geoff purchased and read the book before critiquing it. Whether positive or negative its his opinion and he is entitled to it. Greg has always said that you can have your opinion as long as you don't misrepresent it as a fact. Greg professes that he always focuses on the positive and ignores the negative. If that is true he could have responded in two ways 1) take in the criticism and improve his book in a revised edition, I believe he has done this in his cookbook before; or 2) ignore/defend his book against the criticism. Clearly Greg had chosen the latter and that's perfectly fine if the video ended at that. However Greg took it one step further and went on to respond in a manner which I can only consider as negative by insinuating that Geoffs book is "overcomplicated", "regurgitated copy of others work", not written well needing 30 pages of faq, "struggling to sell despite costing only $8". At least Geoff's opinions were based off on actual facts (contents of the book) whereas Greg, who I'm pretty sure didn't read Geoff's book, made those statements purely on baseless assumptions and conjecture. Just scroll through the comments to see how many people have taken Greg's statements as fact and are shitting all over Geoff's book... wonder how many have actually bought and read it? Who's the one falsely misrepresenting others now? I see comments saying that Geoff is clout-chasing and putting Gregs book down to promote his own... Really? Anyone who's followed Greg long enough should know that he built his channel through making videos on other popular channels/figures and he has always been open about that. In recent months he has been promoting his cookbook and training book in the same way (cookbook>chicken brocoli and rice; training book>RPE etc). Personally I am indifferent to this strategy. You are entitled to your opinion on the morality of it. All I ask is that you keep it consistent.

People do need to watch Geoffrey's video before posting biased comments. He has supported Greg where it was needed and critiqued where it was necessary

Your book is what a veteran teacher would write. He writes his book like he is fresh out of a degree and now using all the terms he was taught.

Seriously missed the boat on this one, he had more praise for you book than he did criticism...

More arrogant-er than last time! Come back to the ground Greg. You're not a messiah, shut the fuck up if you can't take positive criticism.

I’m gonna go buy Geoff’s book now just because of how bad your response to him was lol

3:35 Greg's spit malfunction 😃

this guy's a tryhard gymcoach wannabe that most more amateurish people are in all kinds of fields/industries. They like to think they're covering down to the smallest details but they're just overcomplicating things.

Why tho

Greg gives out charitable views to AMhistory randoms harder than last time

More dishonest than last time

Greg, remember that not too long ago you were also a guy who was struggling to sell his cook book. Just remember that. This defensive shit and cult ish behaviour is not what most of us signed up for.

3:35 made me gag

I would buy Greg's training book... But, i like having two kidneys:) Or if it was below 20$.

Coach Greg ruined my sex life. Now I come faster than last time

Waaaaah someone gave a less than four star review of my ridiculously overpriced training manual waaaaaah Oh screw off dude. Majority of this channel is just outrage and taking other people's content. You can't be making money off of calling out people and then get mad when you get called out, especially when it's respectfully done and justified.

When did coach learn the word “pedantic”? Literally never said it in any videos and now it’s been in EVERY video in the last 2 weeks 😂

Greg's ego is insanely huge and I kinda love it. I die everytime he self-promotes with the angelic music.

As a fan of both Gregs video was edited to make geoffrey seem like a complete villian lol Geoffrey did say good things about Gregs book that were not shown in gregs video, BUT when i watched it (before greg made the review) it did come off as a "reasons why you should get my book and not Gregs book" video. Even though Geoffrey did not say it, thats the kind of vibe i got while watching it.

Respond to his response

I like the information that greg is putting out in the internet, I am also grateful for him because he taught me how to be better than last time. This video maybe by far for me is his weakest one. It was just a 19 min. video of greg being a boomer who could not take criticisms. I also have some encounters with people that are in the age range of doc greg that I called out in school and in my home. No matter how politely I point out my argument and criticisms it will always be deemed as an attack to them even if they're the ones who are really wrong in the first place. Not saying that's the case here but if we can all be eyes and ears we can all be better than last time.

Greg's shirts are just strings at this point. Why even wear them anymore? Let the nipples freee!!!!!

Coach Greg went full Abbey Sharp on Geoff in this one.

Tbh, I liked Jeff Nippard's 'PPL' program more than I liked 'Harder than last time'.

3:36

Very disappointing and hypocritcal response to a fair review. Either you didn't watch Geoff's review fully (which I did after this video) or you're disingenuous. Also $199...jeez

I hear it in my sleep........TRAIN HARDER THAN LAST TIME!!!

Yeah screeching doesn’t win arguments. Geoffrey is a great guy, no bullshit, great advice especially for the natural lifter. How can you take advice from someone who is pumped full of roids unless you are too? Totally changes the parameters.

Coach Greg.. any advice on twice a day training? Is it worth it if its done correctly ... would be great to get your view?

Who TF is Geoffrey...?

It's ok, coach. They can't keep up. They're slower than last time.

Greg's book really costs 200$??

Greg is quite sensitive and easy to get tilted, yes, and sometimes even a little anxious. But for this Geoffrey guy, all I can see is a dude without a future, half-assing his life by moving to China, hoping to get the"foreigner respect &treatment", and half-assing his profession by only scratching the surface of many things. I mean just watch a few videos on his training forms, especially the deadlift.... AMhistory is a free market for competitions, although clout chasing is probably one of the fastest way to grow, I don't see how success can be made by hiding blades under layers of candies namely saying a lot of nice things while meaning otherwise. People want to see drama and bold, straight up characteristics. And with proper executions, great channels can be born. Sorry for the ramblings..